Challenges in predicting the evolutionary maintenance of a phage transgene
© Schmerer et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2014
Received: 20 February 2014
Accepted: 13 July 2014
Published: 1 August 2014
In prior work, a phage engineered with a biofilm-degrading enzyme (dispersin B) cleared artificial, short-term biofilms more fully than the phage lacking the enzyme. An unresolved question is whether the transgene will be lost or maintained during phage growth – its loss would limit the utility of the engineering. Broadly supported evolutionary theory suggests that transgenes will be lost through a ‘tragedy of the commons’ mechanism unless the ecology of growth in biofilms meets specific requirements. We test that theory here.
Functional properties of the transgenic phage were identified. Consistent with the previous study, the dispersin phage was superior to unmodified phage at clearing short term biofilms grown in broth, shown here to be an effect attributable to free enzyme. However, the dispersin phage was only marginally better than control phages on short term biofilms in minimal media and was no better than control phages in clearing long term biofilms. There was little empirical support for the tragedy of the commons framework despite a strong theoretical foundation for its supposed relevance. The framework requires that the transgene imposes an intrinsic cost, yet the transgene was intrinsically neutral or beneficial when expressed from one part of the phage genome. Expressed from a different part of the genome, the transgene did behave as if intrinsically costly, but its maintenance did not benefit from spatially structured growth per se – violating the tragedy framework.
Overall, the transgene was beneficial under many conditions, but no insight to its maintenance was attributable to the established evolutionary framework. The failure likely resides in system details that would be used to parameterize the models. Our study cautions against naive applications of evolutionary theory to synthetic biology, even qualitatively.
Biofilms are persistent bacterial structures that arise in many medical and industrial applications. They are usually undesirable and difficult to control because they are recalcitrant to treatments that eliminate planktonic bacteria [1, 2]. Bacterial viruses – phages – seem to offer a promising technology for biofilm control because they are predators of bacteria and should in theory amplify and persist at the site of biofilms as long as their prey persists. Yet although phage kill bacteria, they are not necessarily endowed with the means to propagate themselves through or degrade a biofilm’s extracellular matrix. Without the ability to penetrate a biofilm, phage may merely graze on planktonic cells exuded by a biofilm without degrading or effecting a long term reduction in bacterial numbers .
Lu and Collins  proposed using engineered phages to enhance biofilm degradation. Their specific application was the addition of a gene encoding the bacterial enzyme dispersin B to the lytic coliphage T7. Dispersin degrades poly-N-acetyl-glucosamine (PNAG), an essential component of E. coli biofilms. The feasibility of their method in short term biofilms was demonstrated with the engineered phage providing better clearing and cell killing than did various control phages lacking the enzyme.
The purpose of the present study is to explore the evolution of this engineered phage – whether it maintains the transgene as the phage grows on biofilms. Dispersin performs its biofilm-degrading function only after an initial cell has been infected, lysed and released the enzyme into the environment. Because the enzyme performs its function outside the cell, the transgene may be lost through an evolutionary ‘tragedy of the commons’ in which the gene benefits not only its own genome but the genomes of unrelated phages lacking the gene. A considerable body of theory and empirical work has supported the tragedy of the commons framework at the organismal level [5–12], but it is not known whether and how that framework can be applied to transgenic phages. If the dispersin transgene is evolutionarily stable, it will help alleviate concerns for other engineered phages and provide impetus for their use. If unstable, can a better transgene design extend its longevity? The hope is that the evolutionary theory can provide broad insight to the fate and design of engineered phages across many contexts and system-specific details.
The addition of a gene to a genome will often have deleterious effects – a cost, c. We conjecture that a cost is nearly universal for an arbitrary transgene but that the bases of that cost lie in intricate molecular details of the phage life cycle, so the magnitude of the cost will be sensitive to details and be quantitatively unpredictable. A transgene may also provide a benefit (b), and the basis of this benefit will often be known or inferred in advance, as it is the motivation for the engineer. It is straightforward to appreciate that a transgene will be favored only if the benefit outweighs the cost: b>c, but understanding how these costs and benefits interact is not always straightforward. For example, in our case, any cost likely operates during the phage intracellular life cycle, whereas benefit comes from modifying the external environment in which the phage grows. The benefit thus varies with environment, but the specific nature of this benefit presents yet an additional problem.
We study a phage genome encoded to produce a transgenic enzyme, dispersin. A transgenic protein of this type is produced within the infected cell, but the expected benefit is to the phage progeny after the bacterium is lysed. After lysis, the enzyme diffuses extracellularly where it can exert its effect on the biofilm exopolysaccharide, releasing bacteria from the biofilm. The benefit is likely one of exposing bacteria to phage that would otherwise be protected by the biofilm matrix. Thus this benefit may well accrue to phages other than the ones encoding the transgene – any phage in the local environment should benefit from the cells exposed by dispersin. Consequently, the transgenic phage may be subject to an evolutionary ‘tragedy of the commons’ in which it experiences a net benefit of the transgene, but other, non-producing phages experience an even greater benefit because their genomes do not suffer the cost. The tragedy is that, even though the transgene is beneficial, phages lacking it are evolutionarily superior and the transgene is outcompeted to extinction.
The foundation for this problem thus rests on three premises. First, there is likely an intrinsic cost to the transgene of unknown magnitude and perhaps little more than a generic consequence of disrupting a wild-type genome (see Discussion for support). Second, the transgene provides a benefit, one that applies only in some environments. There may be many contexts in which the cost exceeds the benefit, but as the benefit depends on environment, there may also be environments in which the benefit exceeds the cost. Third, the specific nature of the benefit is transferable to other phages, leading to the possible evolutionary demise of the transgene even when its benefit exceeds the cost. Avoiding this sharing of benefits is key to evolutionary success of the transgenic phage, as will be expanded upon below.
A mathematical model
The evolutionary process described above is unintuitive, so we offer a mathematical model. Following several precedents [13, 14], the model uses differential equations to describe the dynamics of phage and bacteria in an environment with continuous flow, such as a chemostat, equivalent to a constant death rate. The continuous flow is represented as a constant washout/death rate of all variables. The model assumes mass action, which is most prone to a tragedy of the commons. A more accurate model of the process would include spatial structure (e.g., use partial differential equations), but the main points can be illustrated with the present model without undue emphasis on the mathematics.
The full model (1) has 8 equations that accommodate two bacterial populations and two phage types. One bacterial population exists in a ‘free’ state and is infected by both types of phages. The other bacteria exist in a refuge that fully escapes infection; the refuge population can be considered a physical region free of phages, or it can equally be regarded as planktonic cells whose surface properties protect them from infection. However, refuge bacteria are released at a low rate into the free state, at which point they are susceptible to infection.
Model variables and parameters
Density of free bacteria
Density of refuge bacteria
Density of GM phage
Density of wild phage
Density of enzyme produced by GM phage that increases the release rate of refuge bacteria into the free state rate of both phages
Density of bacteria infected with GM phage (before lysis)
Density of bacteria infected with wild phage (before lysis)
Functions of variables
Rate at which refuge bacteria move to free state
Adsorption rate constant
Burst size of GM phage
Burst size of wild phage
Lysis time (min)
Maximum bacterial growth rate
Enzyme production per lysis
Carrying capacity of environment
Parameters and variables are defined in Table 1; bacterial densities are denoted B and R (free and refuge, respective), phage densities as P G and P W . Bacterial growth in both the free and refuge populations obeys a logistic function with carrying capacity C that applies to the total density of bacteria, B+R. Lysis is modeled as a delay function L minutes after infection, hence a subscript L (e.g., B L , ) indicates the value of the variable L minutes in the past. The baseline rate at which refuge bacteria are released into the free state is 0.01 (per min), increasing up to 0.2 with E according to the function h(E).
The lower two panels illustrate cultures with both phages together; in each panel, one phage is given a lower burst size than the other (17 for one, 20 for the other). Both lower panels show the same general pattern seen in (B) of phages increasing in abundance initially, eventually overwhelming both bacterial populations, and then declining for lack of abundant hosts. However, of specific interest in (C) and (D) are changes in the relative abundances of the two phages (the relative heights of the two phage curves) and the effects of those relative changes on the bacterial dynamics. The two phages start out at 50% frequency in both panels. In (C), the GM phage has the smaller burst and it is progressively lost (dropping to 9% frequency by the end). In (D), the wild phage has the smaller burst, and it is progressively lost (dropping to 10% frequency by the end).
Although the GM phage is responsible for the major impact on bacterial densities (as seen by comparing (A to B), it is progressively lost when the wild phage has the larger burst (in C), which is the tragedy of the commons. The effect of wild phage dominance in (C) is already evident as a reduced impact on and faster rebound of bacterial densities as well as an earlier decline in the release rate of refuge bacteria (compare C to D). If the run in (C) was continued, the system would return to the equilibrium in (A), with a high density of refuge bacteria and only the wild phage present. If the run in (D) was continued, the wild phage would be lost, and both the bacteria and GM phage would cycle between high and low frequencies.
These figures are representative of additional runs (not shown). The details of the dynamics vary (e.g., oscillations dominate some parameter values, densities equilibrate for others), but the GM phage is always progressively lost when it has the lower burst size. Thus the benefit it provides by exposing refuge bacteria does not contribute to its maintenance when both phages are present. It may seem that a tragedy of commons is not relevant when only a single phage type is introduced to a system (e.g., Figure 1B). However, mutations that delete the transgene often quickly arise and convert the population to a mix of types with and without the transgene.
Can the tragedy be avoided?
A widely acknowledged principle for avoiding an evolutionary tragedy of the commons is to impose spatially structured growth [5, 7, 11, 15]. Spatial structure enables an individual and its descendants to be ‘selfish’ by restricting diffusion of its products just to immediate relatives. The spatial structure must be refreshed often enough (e.g., by dispersal and reestablishment) that selfish mutants do not have time to invade. In theory, an engineered phage introduced into a biofilm might avoid the tragedy if there was adequate structured growth. Some observations of phages in biofilms support structured growth , but many dynamical details are unknown, and there may also be a substantial level of phage ‘grazing’ on planktonic cells produced by biofilms .
There is, however, a second layer to the tragedy of the commons that applies to phages: spatially structured growth can work against phages engineered to kill bacteria efficiently and rapidly. In the absence of spatial structure, when phages are mixed in direct competition, phages with higher growth rate have the advantage because they are the fastest to use up all the hosts . In contrast, with spatial structure, phages with low-intermediate growth rates have the advantage because they use their hosts more ‘prudently’ by allowing host numbers to reach high levels before exploiting them. In the long run, those high bacterial densities yield high levels of phage progeny production – higher progeny levels than achieved by phages that kill quickly. Viewed in this light, the advantage of rapid phage growth when phages compete directly, in the absence of spatial structure, is itself a tragedy of the commons .
The benefit to the wild phage of avoiding direct competition with the GM phage can be seen by comparing phage densities in Figure 1A and B. When grown by itself, the GM phage quickly exhausts its hosts and thus realizes only a brief numerical superiority over the wild phage, but outside this window, the wild phage produces more progeny than the GM phage. If spatially structured growth operates so that there is a limited abundance of hosts available at each focus of infection, there may be only a brief window of time in which the GM phage produces more total offspring than the wild phage because it runs out of hosts.
Ironically, therefore, there are two layers to the tragedy of the commons in this problem, and they work against the GM phage both with and without spatial structure. The intrinsic high growth rate of the GM phage would give it the advantage when in direct competition with the wild phage (in the absence of spatial structure) except that it shares its enzyme and thus also boosts the wild phage growth rate - a tragedy that works against the GM phage. Yet the fact that the faster-growing phage wins the direct competition is itself a tragedy, a tragedy that would work in favor of the GM phage if it did not share enzyme. The first tragedy trumps the second, however. Yet when the phages grow with spatial structure, both tragedies are avoided and the wild phage can produce more progeny in the long run because it does not exhaust its hosts quickly.
It is of course possible that spatially structured growth of the phages would conspire to create just the right combination of dynamics to give the advantage to the GM phage. However, even if this were serendipitously achieved in the initial conditions, a further complication is that the degree of spatial structured growth may itself change and decay during phage growth. As phage densities increase and phages diffuse throughout the biofilm, there may be progressively fewer infection foci founded by single phages.
In sum, we can merely conclude at this juncture that the outcome of spatially structured competition is sensitive to subtle and likely unmeasurable details in the growth dynamics. At best, there may be a temporary phase in which the GM phage can avoid a tragedy of the commons, but we are limited to conjecture as to whether a biofilm ever provides the appropriate structure.
A heuristic approach
The transgene will be favored if it provides an intrinsic benefit – one that operates in the absence of a biofilm-structured environment (e.g., a larger burst size). This point is obvious, but we also consider intrinsic benefits to be rare outcomes – we can cite no precedent for a transgene that proved beneficial in the absence of a metabolic modification designed to favor the gene, such as drug resistance (see Discussion). However, even if an intrinsic cost proves to be nearly universal, it is conceivable that engineering can be used to minimize it.
A gene with an intrinsic cost can be favored if its biofilm degradation exposes cells to attack that would otherwise be protected. This condition is not sufficient however, as there must be spatially structured phage growth that strikes a delicate balance between avoiding enzyme sharing with unrelated phages and killing its hosts too quickly. At present, the dynamics of phage growth in biofilm environments have too many unknowns for these conditions to be predictable.
On theoretical grounds, the odds oppose the evolutionary maintenance of phages engineered to degrade biofilms.
The ultimate focus of this paper is evolutionary – the maintenance or loss of the dispersin transgene. Yet the selective basis of a transgene product resides in its phenotypic effect. The first part of Results thus addresses the phenotypic effect of dispersin-bearing phages in several environmental contexts. Phenotype assessment is then followed by evolutionary considerations.
1. The dispersin phenotype meets expectations
Lu and Collins  used a biofilm-clearing assay of intact phages to infer activity of the dispersin transgene. T7 with dispersin outperformed the parental, empty T7 vector as well as a wild-type T3 control. However, T3 substantially outperformed the empty T7 vector, raising the possibility that the dispersin transgene may have augmented biofilm clearing in ways that did not exploit its enzyme activity. Thus we first explore the nature of dispersin’s activity in clearing biofilms: (i) Is biofilm clearing robust to growth conditions? (ii) Does dispersin enzyme alone have the expected effect? Our assays used short-term biofilms broadly similar to those of Lu and Collins – overnight bacterial growth in polystyrene 24-well microtiter plates followed by phage treatment, then assayed with crystal violet (CV) staining. The bacterial strain used was a csrA deletion mutant of E. coli, which overproduces the PNAG substrate digested by dispersin; the mutant exhibits enhanced biofilm production. Untreated and unstained, these overnight biofilms were evident as thin films (less than 1 mm thick) on the bottom and sides of a well.
Various dispersin phages were tested. The specific notation for a phage is T7insert l o c a t i o n , where insert indicates the set of genes added to the phage genome, and the subscript l o c a t i o n indicates the cloning site. ‘T7dsp’ is used generically for convenience when the specific genome has been made clear from the context.
1.A. Short-term biofilms: transgenic phage superiority across various media
1.B. Enzyme alone is sufficient for short-term biofilm degradation
Is the biofilm-clearing effect associated with transgenic dispersin of T7dsp due to enzymatic degradation of the biofilm matrix? Activity of the dispersin protein per se was measured directly with two types of assays. One used a colorimetric indicator specific to dispersin  and yielded a strong signal of activity with a commercially purified enzyme which is an exodepolymerase (Figure 3). In this assay, phage lysates from T7dsp-infected cells failed to produce a signal above background unless they were first concentrated with ammonium sulfate (not shown). Freeze-thaw lysates of bacteria expressing the dispersin B gene from a plasmid yielded a significant signal, approximately 10-fold less than that of the commercial enzyme (Figure 3).
The second measure of dispersin activity used the short-term biofilm clearing assay (Figure 4). Enzyme was added to wells with or without T7v control phage; clearing was assessed with CV staining at 5h treatment. For enzyme from the freeze-thaw lysate used in Figure 3, a monotonic relationship was observed across dilutions, with a significant effect to at least a 100-fold lower concentration than that needed to produce a significant colorimetric signal. It is noteworthy that the commercial dispersin enzyme was totally ineffective in this assay, perhaps reflecting a different enzymatic activity than dsp B on PNAG. There was no significantly greater clearing of biofilms in which enzyme alone was added versus enzyme plus T7v.
2. Long-term biofilms: phage efficacy independent of dispersin
Biofilms were grown 7 days in silicone tubing at 37° in LB. This combination of time and media concentration enabled a robust biofilm to develop without complications of bacterial growth into the delivery or sampling tubes. In contrast to the short term biofilms, the week-old biofilms were visibly thick (several mm) but also irregular in macroscopic structure. They were also delicate in that their structure shifted if the tubing was physically disturbed.
These data clearly present an anomaly: dispersin is essential for clearing short term biofilms but has no significant effect on long term biofilms. It is tempting to attribute the difference to biofilm thickness or gene expression changes with age (e.g., PNAG levels may differ between short term and long term biofilms), but those features are not the only differences between short and long term biofilms. The substrate on which the two biofilms were grown also differed – silicone for the long term biofilms versus treated polystyrene for the short term biofilms. To evaluate whether substrate influenced the dispersin effect, 2 mm thick rings of sterile silicone tubing were added to wells of a polystyrene microtiter plate and a standard short term biofilm was grown; both wells and tubing were then treated with phage in the usual fashion. The polystyrene walls of the microtiter wells were specifically sensitive to T7dsp and were unaffected by control phages; yet by visual inspection the silicone rings in the same wells were equally sensitive to all phages.
The data thus suggest that the properties of a biofilm - and thus its susceptibility to phage infection - is affected by the substrate on which it is initiated. Because substrate-bound cells are only a minor component of a thick, long-term biofilm, it further suggests that the overall architecture of a biofilm is influenced by the nature of binding of that minor component.
The preceding results testify to the benefit of the dispersin transgene in reducing biofilms under some conditions. A question motivating our study is the evolutionary one of whether and under what conditions dispersin will be maintained. In particular, can the general framework of the tragedy of the commons be applied to understand evolution of the transgene?
3.A. Transgene maintenance on long term biofilms
Phage evolution in long term biofilms 1
Final dsp frequency3
3.B. Dispersin cloned in 10B is maintained on planktonic cells, indicating an intrinsic benefit
In the theory section, we suggested that transgene maintenance required either an intrinsic benefit – which seemed unlikely a priori – or required the right combination of spatially structured dynamics. In view of the observed maintenance of dispersin in long term biofilms (section 3.A. Transgene maintenance on long term biofilms, above), we sought to distinguish these alternatives. The straightforward way to demonstrate an intrinsic fitness benefit is to grow the phage in the absence of PNAG or the absence of spatial structure. If the gene is deleterious, it should be lost – as was observed in previous work with an endosialidase transgene in T7 .
Adaptations of various dispersin phages on planktonic IJ1133 (which has normal PNAG expression) revealed that the dispersin transgene was commonly maintained. Many of these outcomes were assessed qualitatively (e.g., the presence of dispersin was indicated by a positive PCR signal in the final culture), but some quantitative experiments were also conducted: (1) a 3 hr adaptation of a recombinant mixture of T7dsp+trx 10B/dsp 10B on IJ1133 in LB followed by single plaque isolation revealed dispersin in all of 10 plaques tested at both the start and end of the adaptation; (2) a similar test using a T7dsp+trx 10B/T7v recombinant mixture detected dispersin in 7 of 10 plaques at the start and in 5 of 10 plaques at the end. These data do not rule out a decline in the fraction of phage genomes that retained the dispersin transgene, but they indicate that any decline is at most modest.
As there is no obvious benefit to degrading extracellular PNAG in planktonic cultures of IJ1133, maintenance of the dispersin transgene evinces either an unexpected benefit to the intracellular phage life cycle or a minimal cost. This is in sharp contrast to transgenic endosialidase . Nevertheless, because dispersin is maintained on planktonic cells, its maintenance in a biofilm cannot be attributed to avoidance of a tragedy of the commons (recall Figure 1D).
3.C. Evolution of dispersin cloned in 3.8: loss on liquid-grown planktonic cells, maintenance in biofilms but also in biofilm-derived planktonic cells
Wild-type (Genbank V01146)
Control phage for some adaptations
T7 cloning vector, made as T7Select 415b-1 (Novagen) with the left end BclI fragment replaced by that of a phage carrying the C74 deletion (gene 0.3 is intact)
Used as backbone for gene insertions because of the cloning site and the ability to grow on hosts containing type I restriction modification (RM)
T7 0 in 
T7415-C74:trxAdspB. T7v with the E. coli trx A gene, T7 ϕ 10 promoter and A. actinomycetemcomitans CU1000 dsp B gene recombined in to the multiple cloning site between genes 10 and 11
Re-engineered version of T7DspB from  to grow on hosts with type I RM
T7dsp+trx 10B/ dsp 10B
T7dsp+trx 10B grown on a host with pUC57-T7dspB to remove the trx A gene by recombination; not clonally isolated
Used to allow evolution of dispersin free of trx A
T7v but most of gene 3.8 replaced with T3 gene 1.2 (enabling growth on F plasmid-bearing strains) and the dsp B gene. Created by recombination with plasmid pMK-RQ-T7trxAdspB. The multiple cloning site in gene 10B is unaltered from T7v.
Used to create T7-1.2+dsp 3.8/dsp 3.8.
T7dsp+1.2 3.8/ dsp 3.8
T7-1.2+dsp 3.8 recombined with pMKRQ-T7dspB to create variation in the presence/absence of the 1.2 gene. Not purified.
Evolved in a chemostat to study evolution of the dsp gene.
The initial mix of T7-1.2+dsp 3.8/dsp 3.8 recombined against the chemostat-evolved population of T7-1.2+dsp 3.8/dsp 3.8 in which the dsp gene had been lost.
Multiple recombinations separated dsp from 1.2 and introduced any mutations from a chemostat adaptation that might be beneficial in the background of the phage. This polymorphic population was used to evaluate the effect of selection on the dsp transgene in serial transfer, short term biofilms and long term biofilms.
Starting with a T7dsp 3.8 shown to have dispersin activity, a polymorphic population was created (denoted T7dsp 3.8P) in which 26% of the phage carried dispersin [credible interval (0.18, 0.36)]. By starting with a mix of different genotypes at intermediate frequencies – as opposed to a pure type – selection quickly leads to an easily detectable change in frequency of the dispersin transgene . Serial transfer of T7dsp 3.8P for 10–12 hr (∼ 40–50 generations) at 37° on planktonic csrA cells in LB broth resulted in apparent loss of the dispersin gene in both of two replicates (undetected in 50 plaques of the final population from one replicate, 40 in the other). The loss of dispersin in liquid serial transfer indicates an intrinsic cost and renders this phage appropriate for testing the role of spatial structure in avoiding a tragedy of the commons. If the biofilm environment is selective for dispersin and if the spatial structure provided by a biofilm avoids a tragedy of the commons, the dispersin gene frequency should be constant or even increase in biofilms.
3.C.1. Long term biofilms
T7dsp 3.8P was introduced to 7-day biofilms. In principle, long term biofilms enable phage evolution to be studied across days rather than hours. However, if a phage destroys the biofilm environment, it may destroy any spatially-structured selection for maintaining the dispersin gene. Typically, the visibly thick matrix of long term biofilms was cleared within 12–24 hr after phage addition, so sampling was conducted early (5–7 hr) and late (70+ hr). In 5 of 6 biofilms, the dispersin transgene initially rose in frequency over 5–7 hours but then declined by 72–74 hr; in the sixth biofilm, an initial decline was followed by a slight rise (Figure 7). Collectively, the dispersin transgene appears to be favored or maintained early in biofilm attack but not long term.
3.C.2. Short term biofilms
The dispersin transgene has a dramatic effect on short term biofilms. It was thus of special interest to determine whether the dispersin transgene would also realize a major evolutionary advantage in that treatment. For reasons noted above, it was necessary to use T7dsp 3.8P for this test, as the transgene appears to be intrinsically beneficial in T7dsp 10B. To control for as many variables as possible while comparing the effect of planktonic versus biofilm-embedded cells, planktonic cells were obtained from the first rinse of an overnight biofilm well using fresh media and deposited in an empty well where no biofilm was present. (Microscopic observations on washes confirmed that cells were either single or in small clusters of 5–20 cells that should allow free phage access independent of dispersin.) The well containing the original biofilm was replenished with fresh media. Thus one well had a biofilm and the other had only planktonic cells derived from it. T7dsp 3.8P was added to both wells, and the frequency of the dispersin transgene compared between them after 5 hr of growth.
Organisms with engineered genomes are finding ever-increasing applications (e.g., [22–25]). Commonly, those engineered organisms must reproduce themselves to perform their function, whether in a fermenter, patient, or field. That reproduction virtually ensures their evolution, evolution that may reverse the engineering, improve it, or allow its escape. Being able to predict that evolution will have many benefits that span social impacts to corporate finances. The present study is broadly viewed as a test case of this perspective, predicting the evolution of an engineered genome. Overall, the results challenge the expectation that evolution can be predicted from general principles applied naively.
The effort here used an established transgenic phage system. Lu and Collins  engineered a T7 to encode the bacterial gene for dispersin, which degrades an exopolysaccharide component of biofilms (poly-N-acetyl-glucosamine or PNAG). In support of their design principle, the engineered phage cleared short-term biofilms more completely than did control phages. What was not tested was whether the phage would retain the dispersin gene and activity during growth in biofilms. This latter issue is one of evolutionary stability, and it intersects the domains of ecology and evolution, where there are well established principles that might be expected to govern the fate of engineered phages [5–12].
The crux of the evolutionary problem faced by this phage was thought to reside in a framework known as ‘tragedy of the commons’. It was assumed that dispersin would not be beneficial to the intracellular phage life cycle, but that it might benefit the phage population by degrading the biofilm matrix and thereby increasing phage access to cells; data from Lu and Collins supported this latter point. But a benefit to the phage population is not the same as a benefit to the transgenic genome: the dispersin protein is released at lysis as a free protein that diffuses and degrades the matrix in the local environment. Thus any and all phages in this local environment benefit, not just the genome that produced the enzyme. The intrinsic cost of the transgene – incurred only by the genome encoding it – then leads to its evolutionary loss when competing with phages lacking the transgene.
Well established theory suggests that the tragedy might be avoided if the phage is ‘selfish’, as by growing in a physically structured environment that limits sharing of the transgenic protein. But even this solution requires a delicate balance of dynamical properties. Based on these a priori considerations, evolutionary maintenance of the dispersin transgene seemed unlikely but not impossible, but that spatially structured growth was required.
The naive application of the evolutionary framework failed because one of the main assumptions failed: the transgene was not intrinsically deleterious. It is of course possible to offer reasons post hoc why an arbitrary transgene might have virtually no cost (e.g., restoring genome length closer to wild-type), but previous work points to nearly ubiquitous deleterious effects of engineered changes in T7 [15, 26, 27] (including unpublished observations on trx A inserts) and even bacteria . The failure is thus one of the approach used here, extrapolating seemingly generic properties of transgene effects observed in other contexts to dispersin. In short, details matter when predicting evolution. This is an unfortunate message, because virtually any application of evolutionary principles to real world systems will require many levels of similarly naive assumptions – implementation will never await knowing all details in advance (e.g., [23, 24]).
The transgenic phage dramatically augmented clearing of short-term biofilms in two different media but had only a modest effect in a third. Adding enzyme alone to short term biofilms could reproduce the effect. The effect of media was not explored further but could be a consequence of varying concentrations of PNAG production relative to other biofilm exopolysaccharides. These observations are broadly compatible with those expected from previous work  except for the effect of media.
The dispersin transgene offered no benefit in clearing long-term biofilms, the environment of greatest potential utility. The contrast with dispersin’s effect in short term biofilms was partly attributable to a different architecture of the two types of biofilms, suggesting that even preliminary laboratory studies on biofilm remediation should be focused on the conditions of end use.
During growth in both long- and short-term biofilms, the transgene was beneficial and its frequency increased at least temporarily. Whereas the evolutionary theory dictated that this benefit should stem from or be enhanced by spatial architecture of the biofilm, the benefit merely reflected the specific physiology of cells growing in a biofilm. Bacteria sloughed from the biofilms provided an equal or superior benefit to the transgenic phage. There was thus no insight or outcome attributable to the tragedy of commons framework.
The results indicate that maintenance of a transgene depends both on intrinsic properties of the transgene and on engineering. Although the tragedy framework did not obviously apply to dispersin maintenance, the basis of that model failure is a good one from an engineering perspective: the transgene was intrinsically beneficial. In cases where the transgene is intrinsically costly and a tragedy of the commons is not averted, nature may suggest ways to engineer a solution. Specifically, some naturally-occurring phage depolymerases enhance biofilm degradation [3, 29, 30]. Those enzymes are typically encoded as virion tailspikes and are required for infection, thus directly benefitting the parent genome; they are not subject to loss through a tragedy of the commons. Engineering enzymes as phage tail components may thus enable maintenance of a transgene when it would otherwise be lost.
Strains and media
E. coli K-12 F -Δ lacX74 thi Δ (mcrC-mrr)102::Tn10
Host for measuring phage titers and some serial transfers to determine the evolutionary stability of the dsp B transgene in the absence of an extracellular PNAG matrix.
E. coli B Gal -dcm ompT hsdS(r B - m B -) [ λ(DE3)]
Host for protein expression
E. coli K12 Δ lacX74 supE44 galK2 galT22 mcrA rfbD1 mcrB1 hsdS3 /F ′lac
Host for selecting T7 carrying T3 gene 1.2
JW5856 (Keio Δ trxA::kan)
Host for selection of positive phage recombinants carrying trxA
E. coli K-12 F -Δ lacU169 Δ csrA::kan
Biofilm host; overproduces PNAG, the substrate for dispersin B
TR1-5 mutant in 
JW1083 (Keio Δ nagZ::kan)
Host with low background activity for producing dispersin B protein from phage lysates
The E. coli trx A gene, or alternatively T3 1.2 was used as a selectable marker in detecting initial recombinants but has no benefit afterward in our design. Consequently, the evolutionary fate of the dispersin B gene may be considered to have been influenced by trx A. However, some adaptations used a recombinant mix that deleted trx A from the dispersin transgene, and other adaptations were observed to spontaneously delete trx A while maintaining dispersin. Thus trx A is not expected to affect the evolutionary fate of dispersin. All adaptations of phages in which T3 1.2 had been used as a selectable marker were recombinant mixtures that included phages carrying dispersin but lacking T3 1.2, so again, this marker would not affect selection of the dispersin B gene.
Plasmid pET15b-dspB was the commercial vector pET15b with an insert of bases 1-1086 of the dispersin B (dspB) ORF from Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans CU1000 (Genbank AY228551). Although this fragment is not the complete ORF, it has beta-hexosaminidase activity . pUC57-T7dspB consisted of the vector pUC57 with a linear insert in order of (i) T7Select 415b-1 bases 21403-21503 (Novagen), (ii) the ϕ 10 T7 promoter, (iii) a ribosomal binding sequence, (iv) bases 1-1086 of the A. actinomycetemcomitans dspB ORF, and (v) T7Select 415b-1 nts. 21517-21617. pUC57-T7trxAdspB consisted of pUC57-T7dspB with the E. coli trxA gene inserted between T7Select 415b-1 nts. 21403-21503 and the ϕ 10 promoter. pMKRQ-T71.2+dspB consisted of plasmid pMK-RQ (Gene Art) with an insert of T7 bases 11059-11229 (5’ of gene 3.8) followed by T3 gene 1.2, dspB, and T7 bases 11550-11652 (the 3’ end of 3.8). pMKRQ-T7dspB was pMKRQ-T71.2+dspB without the T3 1.2 gene.
Recombinant phage construction
Recombinant phages were obtained by first plating T7v on a host containing a plasmid that carried an insert of dspB with a selectable marker (trx A or T3 1.2) and T7 flanking sequences. Plaques, which invariably contained a mixture of recombinants and T7v, were suspended and replated on an appropriate selection host. These second-step plaques were then usually purified in a subsequent round of plating and the presence of dispersin checked phenotypically and/or by PCR.
The phages at this step carried not only the dispersin gene but a selectable marker that might have imposed a fitness cost. To eliminate the selectable marker, phages were plated on a host carrying a plasmid that would recombine out the selectable marker but leave intact the dsp gene. In some cases, isolates lacking the selectable marker were identified by screening for inability to grow on the Δ trxA host and then confirmed by PCR. In other cases, the entire polymorphic plaque was used, as selection would be able to separate the selectable marker from dsp.
Dispersin B protein expression and activity assay
BL21 (DE3) cells with pET15b or pET15b-dsp were grown to log phase in 10 mL of LB broth at 37°C. IPTG was added to 1 mM and the cultures grown for 3 hr. Cells were pelleted, resuspended in 0.5 mL of lysis buffer (100 mM NaCl, 20 mM Tris-HCl pH 8.0, 6 mM MgSO 4 and 0.5 mg/mL lysozyme), subjected to two rounds of freeze-thaw and cleared by centrifugation. Lysates were stored at 4°C, maintaining activity for at least one month.
Chemical activity of dspB protein was assessed using the colorimetric substrate 4-nitrophenyl N-acetyl- β-glucosaminide (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO) at 1 mM . Commercial β-N-acetylglucosaminidase (New England Biolabs, Ipswitch, MA), an exoglycosidase, was used as an enzyme standard. Reactions followed manufacturer instructions using the recommended buffer. Reactions were incubated for 30 min at 37°C and stopped with 100 mM glycine pH 10. Absorbance at 405 nm was measured using the UV-Vis module of the NanoDrop Spectrophotometer (Thermo Scientific, Wilmington, DE).
One preparation of dspB enzyme used lysates of dispersin phages. Δ nagZ cells were grown at 37°C with aeration in 50 mL LB broth to a density of approximately 108 cells/mL. 1×104 phage per mL were added to each culture and the cultures grown until visible lysis (2 hr). Protein from lysates was precipitated with saturated ammonium sulfate, pelleted and resuspended in 0.5 mL of buffer (20 mM Tris-HCl pH 8, 50 mM NaCl, 1 mM EDTA, pH 8). For controls, phage-free lysates of Δ nagZ cells were grown, pelleted and lysed by freeze-thaw as described above. Protein from the cleared cell lysate was precipitated using saturated ammonium sulfate, pelleted and resuspended in 0.05 mL buffer.
Aliquots (100 μ L) of Δ csrA cells were made as 10-fold concentrates of a stationary phase culture, frozen in LB with 20% glycerol. An aliquot was suspended in 12 mL media and 1 mL was added to each well of a 24-well tissue culture plate (Corning with Standard Tissue Culture Treated Surface). Cells were grown overnight in a static 37°C incubator. After 12–16 hr, the media was replaced and supplemented with 104 – 105 phage per well or with a lysate containing enzyme. The plate was then incubated 5 hr in a static 37°C incubator. After treatment, wells were rinsed once with water, air dried, stained for 15 min with crystal violet (CV, 0.1% in water), rinsed twice in water, and then air dried. Residual CV was extracted in 95% ethanol and quantified by absorbance at 560 nm using the UV-Vis module of the NanoDrop Spectrophotometer (Thermo Scientific, Wilmington, DE).
Biofilms of Δ csrA cells were grown in LB for 7 days in silicone tubing (20 cm, 0.125" I.D. x 0.250" O.D; VWR International LLC, Radnor, PA). An additional length of tubing connected the biofilm chamber to a waste container. Luer-lock stopcocks at each end of the chamber tubing allowed sterile introduction and sampling of phage and cells. Media flow rate was kept at 3 mL/hr. The biofilm chambers were placed on a covered slide warmer set at 37°C. The cell preparation was the same as for short-term biofilms. After inoculation, cells were incubated statically for 1 hr to allow attachment prior to reinstating media flow.
Biofilms were grown for 7 days, then 104 phage were added. The biofilm was grown a further 4–5 days. Biofilm effluents were assayed for phage daily. After phage treatment, chambers were rinsed once with water and dried. Crystal violet staining assessed biofilm mass.
Growth of phage for testing loss of transgene
Evolutionary stability of transgene maintenance was carried out on IJ1133 in LB or on Δ csrA in LB. Eight lines used 3 hr of serial transfer on IJ1133 following established methods [36, 37]. One line was grown 48 hr by continuous culture in a 2-tube chemostat .
Statistics of dispersin transgene frequency
Standard PCR was used to measure the presence or absence of the dispersin gene in phage isolates to obtain frequency estimates from a population. Primer pairs consisted of one internal and one flanking dispersin, or both flanking. When the frequency of the target sequence is high or low, nearly all phage will be of the same type, and a large number of single-plaque reactions are required to estimate the frequency. Combining multiple plaques into a single reaction facilitates the detection of uncommon types by reducing the number of reactions needed. However, the statistics of sampling error become somewhat more complicated. We used the following methods:
where A=U n , B=T n , and C=1-U n -T n and X+Y+Z=R (the combinatorial constant term is omitted). M(A,B,C,X,Y,Z) is easily solved for the maximum likelihood estimate of T, and a 95% Bayesian ‘credible’ interval obtained by treating the normalized M(A,B,C,X,Y,Z) as a probability density function of T (0≤T≤1) and finding the bounds for the upper and lower 2.5% tails.
Figures were drawn in R .
Differential equations were evaluated numerically in the program Berkeley Madonna (v. 9.0.118 beta) with a step size of 10-3 and the Euler method. The numerical output was transferred to R for presentation.
We thank L. Forney for advice and instruction on E. coli laboratory biofilm growth. Tim Lu sent us his T7 dispersin phage, which got the project started. N. Ramasubbu advised us on a colorimetric dispersin substrate. We thank a reviewer for pointing out that the spatially structured dynamics of phage growth in a biofilm may be dynamic. Supported by NIH GM 57756 and U. Texas Miescher Regents Professorship to JJB. We thank RJ Bull for some sequence analysis of preliminary adaptations (not reported here).
- Donlan RM, Costerton JW: Biofilms: survival mechanisms of clinically relevant microorganisms. Clin Microbiol Rev 2002,15(2):167-193.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Worthington RJ, Richards JJ, Melander C: Small molecule control of bacterial biofilms. Org Biomol Chem 2012,10(37):7457-7474.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Cornelissen A, Ceyssens P, Van Praet H, Noben J, Shaburova OV, Krylov VN, Volckaert G, Lavigne R, T’Syen J: The T7-related Pseudomonas putida phage ϕ 15 displays virion-associated biofilm degradation properties . PloS One 2011,6(4):e18597.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lu TK, Collins JJ: Dispersing biofilms with engineered enzymatic bacteriophage. PNAS 2007,104(27):11197-11202.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- West SA, Griffin AS, Gardner A, Diggle SP: Social evolution theory for microorganisms. Nat Rev Microbiol 2006,4(8):597-607.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Xavier JB, Foster KR: Cooperation and conflict in microbial biofilms. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2007,104(3):876-881.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- MacLean RC: The tragedy of the commons in microbial populations insights from theoretical, comparative and experimental studies. Heredity 2008,100(5):471-477.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bull JJ, Harcombe WR: Population dynamics constrain the cooperative evolution of cross-feeding. PloS One 2009, 4: e4115.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kummerli R, Griffin AS, West SA, Buckling A, Harrison F: Viscous medium promotes cooperation in the pathogenic bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa . Proc Biol Sci R Soc 2009,276(1672):3531-3538.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Eshelman CM, Vouk R, Stewart JL, Halsne E, Lindsey HA, Schneider S, Gualu M, Dean AM, Kerr B: Unrestricted migration favours virulent pathogens in experimental metapopulations: evolutionary genetics of a rapacious life history. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2010,365(1552):2503-2513.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Frank SA: Demography and the tragedy of the commons. J Evol Biol 2010, 23: 32-39.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Smith J: Tragedy of the commons among antibiotic resistance plasmids. Evolution 2012,66(4):1269-1274.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Levin BR, Stewart FM, Chao L: Resource-limited growth, competition, and predation - a model and experimental studies with bacteria and bacteriophage. Am Nat 1977,111(977):3-24.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Levin BR, Bull JJ: Population and evolutionary dynamics of phage therapy. Nat Rev Microbiol 2004,2(2):166-173.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gladstone EG, Molineux IJ, Bull JJ: Evolutionary principles and synthetic biology: avoiding a molecular tragedy of the commons with an engineered phage. J Biol Eng 2012, 6: 13.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Doolittle MM, Cooney JJ, Caldwell DE: Tracing the interaction of bacteriophage with bacterial biofilms using fluorescent and chromogenic probes. J Ind Microbiol 1996,16(6):331-341.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Manuel SGA, Ragunath C, Sait HBR, Izano EA, Kaplan JB, Ramasubbu N: Role of actie-site residues of dispersin B, a biofilm-releasing beta-hexosaminidase from a periodontal pathogen, in substrate hydrolysis. FEBS J 2007,274(22):5987-5999.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Schrag SJ, Mittler JE: Host-parasite coexistence: the role of spatial refuges in stabilizing bacteria-phage interactions. Amer Natur 1996,148(2):348-377.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Molineux I: The T7 group. In The Bacteriophages. Edited by: Calendar R. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2005:277-301.Google Scholar
- Dunn JJ, Studier FW: Complete nucleotide sequence of bacteriophage T7 DNA and the locations of T7 genetic elements. J Mol Biol 1983,166(4):477-535. [PMID: 6864790]View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Rokyta D, Badgett MR, Molineux IJ, Bull JJ: Experimental genomic evolution: extensive compensation for loss of DNA ligase activity in a virus. Mol Biol Evol 2002,19(3):230-238.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Burns CC, Campagnoli R, Shaw J, Vincent A, Jorba J, Kew OM: Genetic inactivation of poliovirus infectivity by increasing the frequencies of CpG, and UpA dinucleotides within and across synonymous capsid region codons. J Virol 2009,83(19):9957-9969. [PMID: 19605476]View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gould F: Broadening the application of evolutionarily based genetic pest management. Evolution 2008,62(2):500-510.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bull JJ, Turelli M: Wolbachia versus dengue: evolutionary forecasts. Evol Med Public Health 2013, 2013: 197-207.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Paddon CJ, Keasling JD: Semi-synthetic artemisinin: a model for the use of synthetic biology in pharmaceutical development. Nat Rev Microbiol 2014,12(5):355-367.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Cecchini N, Schmerer M, Molineux IJ, Springman R, Bull JJ: Evolutionarily stable attenuation by genome rearrangement in a virus. G3 (Bethesda, Md.) 2013,3(8):1389-1397.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Springman R, Molineux IJ, Duong C, Bull RJ, Bull JJ: Evolutionary stability of a refactored phage genome. ACS Synthetic Biol 2012,1(9):425-430.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sleight SC, Bartley BA, Lieviant JA, Sauro HM: Designing and engineering evolutionary robust genetic circuits. J Biol Eng 2010, 4: 12.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hanlon GW, Denyer SP, Olliff CJ, Ibrahim LJ: Reduction in exopolysaccharide viscosity as an aid to bacteriophage penetration through Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms . Appl Environ Microbiol 2001,67(6):2746-2753.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hughes KA, Sutherland IW, Jones MV: Biofilm susceptibility to bacteriophage attack: the role of phage-borne polysaccharide depolymerase. Microbiology 1998, 144(Pt 11): 3039-3047.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- García LR, Molineux IJ: Rate of translocation of bacteriophage T7, DNA across the membranes of Escherichia coli . J Bacteriol 1995,177(14):4066-4076.Google Scholar
- Studier FW, Moffatt BA: Use of bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase to direct selective high-level expression of cloned genes. J Mol Biol 1986, 189: 113-130.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Baba T, Ara T, Hasegawa M, Takai Y, Okumura Y, Baba M, Datsenko KA, Tomita M, Wanner BL, Mori H: Construction of Escherichia coli K-12 in-frame, single-gene knockout mutants: the Keio collection . Mol Syst Biol 2006, 2: 2006.0008.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Romeo T, Gong M, Liu MY, Brun-Zinkernagel AM: Identification and molecular characterization of csrA, a pleiotropic gene from Escherichia coli that affects glycogen biosynthesis, gluconeogenesis, cell size, and surface properties . J Bacteriol 1993,175(15):4744-4755.Google Scholar
- Kaplan JB, Ragunath C, Ramasubbu N, Fine DH: Detachment of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans biofilm cells by an endogenous beta-hexosaminidase activity. J Bacteriol 2003,185(16):4693-4698.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Heineman RH, Bull JJ: Testing optimality with experimental evolution lysis time in a bacteriophage. Evolution 2007,61(7):1695-1709.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bull JJ, Heineman RH, Wilke CO: The phenotype-fitness map in experimental evolution of phages. PloS One 2011,6(11):e27796.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bull JJ: Optimality models of phage life history and parallels in disease evolution. J Theor Biol 2006,241(4):928-38.MathSciNetView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- R Development Core Team: R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing; 2012. . [ISBN 3-900051-07-0] [http://www.R-project.org/] . [ISBN 3-900051-07-0]Google Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.